{"schema_version":"comparison_page_v1_scores_aggregate","generated_at":"2026-09-15T13:06:51.769338+00:00","test_set_size":1536,"gallery_cohort_size":1522,"reference":"OURS-seed2027-step12000","reference_id":"ours","methods":[{"id":"ours","label":"OURS (AfterImage3D)","baseline_id":"OURS-seed2027-step12000","kind":"reference"},{"id":"base","label":"BASE","baseline_id":"BASE","kind":"internal"},{"id":"teacher","label":"Teacher-II","baseline_id":"TEACHER-II","kind":"internal"},{"id":"direct25","label":"Direct25","baseline_id":"DIRECT25_APPLE","kind":"external"},{"id":"lgm","label":"LGM","baseline_id":"LGM_BIG_FIXROT_MVDREAM","kind":"external"},{"id":"shape","label":"Shap-E","baseline_id":"SHAPE_TEXT300M","kind":"external"},{"id":"ln3diff","label":"LN3Diff","baseline_id":"LN3DIFF_T23D","kind":"external"},{"id":"instantmesh","label":"InstantMesh","baseline_id":"FLUX1DEV_INSTANTMESH_LARGE","kind":"external"},{"id":"topia","label":"3DTopia-XL","baseline_id":"THREEDTOPIA_XL_T23D","kind":"external"},{"id":"hunyuan_fr40k","label":"Hunyuan3D-2 (FR40K accelerated)","baseline_id":"HUNYUAN3D2_FR40K_ACCEL_V1","kind":"external"},{"id":"ours_b3","label":"OURS (best-of-3 seed oracle, post-hoc)","baseline_id":"OURS-seed2027/26/28-step12000","kind":"ours_variant"},{"id":"ours_s2026","label":"OURS-seed2026-step12000","baseline_id":"OURS-seed2026-step12000","kind":"ours_seed"},{"id":"ours_s2028","label":"OURS-seed2028-step12000","baseline_id":"OURS-seed2028-step12000","kind":"ours_seed"},{"id":"scale2k","label":"SCALE-2K-R10","baseline_id":"SCALE-2K-R10","kind":"internal_ablation"},{"id":"teacher_it","label":"Teacher-IT","baseline_id":"TEACHER-IT","kind":"internal_ablation"}],"aggregates":{"ours":{"clip12_average":{"n":1529,"mean":0.30207639394264246,"median":0.3017452172935009,"std":0.0230978815151579,"p25":0.28737775733073556,"p75":0.317499486108621,"min":0.21267693241437277,"max":0.37935277447104454,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.30207639394264246,"delta_mean":0.0,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0,"delta_median":0.0,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":0,"ties":1529}},"clip12_best":{"n":1529,"mean":0.32013495756645777,"median":0.32081620395183563,"std":0.02311403770114487,"p25":0.3048715889453888,"p75":0.3351796567440033,"min":0.24017129093408585,"max":0.41659019887447357,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.32013495756645777,"delta_mean":0.0,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0,"delta_median":0.0,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":0,"ties":1529}},"uni3d":{"n":1529,"mean":0.19403917446459643,"median":0.1934235841035843,"std":0.05232589827868412,"p25":0.15858720988035202,"p75":0.23021069169044495,"min":0.046505773440003395,"max":0.3526322990655899,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.19403917446459643,"delta_mean":0.0,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0,"delta_median":0.0,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":0,"ties":1529}}},"base":{"clip12_average":{"n":1528,"mean":0.2978618147288876,"median":0.29802534729242325,"std":0.023757571056436198,"p25":0.2826380201925834,"p75":0.31423281878232956,"min":0.214528185625871,"max":0.3722275632123152,"paired":{"n":1522,"reference_mean":0.3020784974341337,"method_mean":0.2978768030192133,"delta_mean":0.004201694414920312,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.004201694414920312,"delta_median":0.0036326488479971886,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":907,"losses":615,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1528,"mean":0.3163599201834015,"median":0.3169279545545578,"std":0.02360175032099115,"p25":0.3010537661612034,"p75":0.332466222345829,"min":0.22842587530612946,"max":0.3792778551578522,"paired":{"n":1522,"reference_mean":0.3201498906868516,"method_mean":0.31637762525117663,"delta_mean":0.003772265435674971,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.003772265435674971,"delta_median":0.003321722149848938,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":899,"losses":623,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1528,"mean":0.18992861388592508,"median":0.19073885306715965,"std":0.04911283212330163,"p25":0.1554384883493185,"p75":0.22275329940021038,"min":0.039147473871707916,"max":0.3392001986503601,"paired":{"n":1522,"reference_mean":0.19407054386132258,"method_mean":0.18996179503549024,"delta_mean":0.00410874882583236,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.00410874882583236,"delta_median":0.0030247140675783157,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":815,"losses":707,"ties":0}}},"teacher":{"clip12_average":{"n":1532,"mean":0.30667461477685315,"median":0.30744931722680724,"std":0.024747192212397337,"p25":0.2913453911120693,"p75":0.322406247879068,"min":0.1977723315358162,"max":0.3869597154359023,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.30207113850882145,"method_mean":0.3066180022952498,"delta_mean":-0.004546863786428352,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.004546863786428352,"delta_median":-0.005017685393492455,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":620,"losses":905,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1532,"mean":0.3270985201127613,"median":0.3276125565171242,"std":0.024991494446108705,"p25":0.31103021278977394,"p75":0.3431992679834366,"min":0.20583032071590424,"max":0.40341176092624664,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.3201090326563257,"method_mean":0.3270736261225138,"delta_mean":-0.006964593466188087,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.006964593466188087,"delta_median":-0.007344141602516174,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":565,"losses":960,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1532,"mean":0.1918222225148367,"median":0.19173111766576767,"std":0.05799821728570715,"p25":0.15169359743595123,"p75":0.23312462121248245,"min":0.0028799017891287804,"max":0.34913915395736694,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.19399308602340887,"method_mean":0.19184199256059087,"delta_mean":0.0021510934628179816,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0021510934628179816,"delta_median":-0.000582672655582428,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":755,"losses":770,"ties":0}}},"direct25":{"clip12_average":{"n":1536,"mean":0.2734890003965928,"median":0.2742825935905178,"std":0.024528274115503974,"p25":0.2579420379673441,"p75":0.29026946394393843,"min":0.1797381304204464,"max":0.34717634941140807,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.27358055192386765,"delta_mean":0.028495842018774812,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.028495842018774812,"delta_median":0.02841678075492382,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1259,"losses":270,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.02697925460042648,0.029984029581695583],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1536,"mean":0.2988906681421213,"median":0.29902806878089905,"std":0.025130740033935846,"p25":0.28203242272138596,"p75":0.3152477405965328,"min":0.21267609298229218,"max":0.38211941719055176,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.29898627942453576,"delta_mean":0.021148678141922013,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.021148678141922013,"delta_median":0.02045917510986328,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1148,"losses":381,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.01964830670279175,0.022677434232765706],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1536,"mean":0.14096518368675484,"median":0.13828732445836067,"std":0.05035118872981727,"p25":0.10512956324964762,"p75":0.17515456303954124,"min":0.002028845250606537,"max":0.3091028481721878,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.1410398878846342,"delta_mean":0.05299928657996223,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.05299928657996223,"delta_median":0.05009519308805466,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1227,"losses":302,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.04989813928609772,0.056114787012595986],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"lgm":{"clip12_average":{"n":1536,"mean":0.30014009430386873,"median":0.3001999345918497,"std":0.02325704207634312,"p25":0.2841083537787199,"p75":0.31529999369134504,"min":0.2222677475462357,"max":0.3813355229794979,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.3002459253544885,"delta_mean":0.0018304685881539633,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0018304685881539633,"delta_median":0.002271812409162577,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":817,"losses":712,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.0005779066802221169,0.0030943590796714817],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1536,"mean":0.320994864499274,"median":0.32113897055387497,"std":0.023276915830081627,"p25":0.3052000626921654,"p75":0.33613862097263336,"min":0.23960623145103455,"max":0.4006354659795761,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.3210829179453803,"delta_mean":-0.0009479603789225367,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.0009479603789225367,"delta_median":-0.0009496957063674927,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":735,"losses":794,"ties":0,"ci95":[-0.0021845848487776587,0.00027087622494519016],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"shape":{"clip12_average":{"n":1536,"mean":0.27383888552604835,"median":0.2734838615482052,"std":0.025107650185161468,"p25":0.25746082576612633,"p75":0.29038404316330946,"min":0.165544622267286,"max":0.3515579762558142,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.27381407104839467,"delta_mean":0.028262322894247797,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.028262322894247797,"delta_median":0.027789008493224743,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1297,"losses":232,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.02683194036233004,0.029699838982964254],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1536,"mean":0.2967923089260391,"median":0.2962098717689514,"std":0.023684475374884724,"p25":0.2815626822412014,"p75":0.3126620277762413,"min":0.198703333735466,"max":0.3809511810541153,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.29678414006729076,"delta_mean":0.023350817499167002,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.023350817499167002,"delta_median":0.022613301873207092,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1235,"losses":294,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.02196812815744944,0.024735768479730587],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1536,"mean":0.16539670061380699,"median":0.16616951115429401,"std":0.047540448369680355,"p25":0.13572110794484615,"p75":0.19701002538204193,"min":0.024939553812146187,"max":0.3091437816619873,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.1653980538474385,"delta_mean":0.028641120617157928,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.028641120617157928,"delta_median":0.027437724173069,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1044,"losses":485,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.025889072993156872,0.03144007403814057],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"ln3diff":{"clip12_average":{"n":1530,"mean":0.24010089553734348,"median":0.2406820949787895,"std":0.03072319386830673,"p25":0.22076658609633645,"p75":0.25918763658652705,"min":0.11331559717655182,"max":0.3332689752181371,"paired":{"n":1523,"reference_mean":0.302092471338758,"method_mean":0.24021378033022944,"delta_mean":0.06187869100852852,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.06187869100852852,"delta_median":0.060685547068715096,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1461,"losses":62,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.06005220788987698,0.06370909092027016],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1530,"mean":0.26338189519406147,"median":0.2647659331560135,"std":0.030062694676724594,"p25":0.24494170397520065,"p75":0.2830064669251442,"min":0.126974917948246,"max":0.3551633358001709,"paired":{"n":1523,"reference_mean":0.3201427861353479,"method_mean":0.2634746668100827,"delta_mean":0.05666811932526524,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.05666811932526524,"delta_median":0.055575400590896606,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1436,"losses":87,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.0548184116777627,0.058490825597458544],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1530,"mean":0.11285208464650365,"median":0.11189069412648678,"std":0.04230367942540858,"p25":0.08420178759843111,"p75":0.14124338794499636,"min":-0.036220733076334,"max":0.2757968455553055,"paired":{"n":1523,"reference_mean":0.19412919007319998,"method_mean":0.11281525927651746,"delta_mean":0.08131393079668252,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.08131393079668252,"delta_median":0.07925498485565186,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1373,"losses":150,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.07824622070109259,0.08434272874267663],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"instantmesh":{"clip12_average":{"n":1536,"mean":0.3029118885577999,"median":0.30325618820885814,"std":0.023842812608728805,"p25":0.2876321142539382,"p75":0.31781270323942107,"min":0.19216570009787878,"max":0.38046787555019057,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.30291425702589475,"delta_mean":-0.0008378630832523099,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.0008378630832523099,"delta_median":-0.0014239599307378503,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":713,"losses":816,"ties":0,"ci95":[-0.0019228190226581463,0.00024018866525313772],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1536,"mean":0.32411133203519665,"median":0.32380537688732147,"std":0.024105739794741142,"p25":0.3092040829360485,"p75":0.3392900303006172,"min":0.22502171248197556,"max":0.4205997735261917,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.3241389793574693,"delta_mean":-0.0040040217910115436,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.0040040217910115436,"delta_median":-0.003981053829193115,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":636,"losses":893,"ties":0,"ci95":[-0.005091475190910309,-0.0029336839031118673],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1536,"mean":0.1752271663732851,"median":0.1728120520710945,"std":0.05279507816345148,"p25":0.13962904177606106,"p75":0.20872106589376926,"min":-0.037970831617712975,"max":0.3543736934661865,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.17525258261139065,"delta_mean":0.018786591853205775,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.018786591853205775,"delta_median":0.016341976821422577,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":969,"losses":560,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.016120209470213108,0.02141105101009535],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"topia":{"clip12_average":{"n":1522,"mean":0.25675233413473075,"median":0.2570118351529042,"std":0.025591209995693205,"p25":0.23983745804677406,"p75":0.2739535303165515,"min":0.16040706044683856,"max":0.33400706574320793,"paired":{"n":1515,"reference_mean":0.3020888703638571,"method_mean":0.25669703579336667,"delta_mean":0.04539183457049042,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.04539183457049042,"delta_median":0.04354960036774469,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1422,"losses":93,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.043855131671439174,0.04694189071037466],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1522,"mean":0.28135025454256757,"median":0.28261105716228485,"std":0.024720248744639312,"p25":0.26460093446075916,"p75":0.2981872707605362,"min":0.2042323425412178,"max":0.34921279549598694,"paired":{"n":1515,"reference_mean":0.32016004956398075,"method_mean":0.28128453212799415,"delta_mean":0.03887551743598661,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.03887551743598661,"delta_median":0.03822091221809387,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1358,"losses":157,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.03731618641651306,0.04042776029188149],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1522,"mean":0.1483650680236107,"median":0.14831536263227463,"std":0.04892743720220432,"p25":0.1151182297617197,"p75":0.18175978772342205,"min":0.0007860595360398293,"max":0.28860901296138763,"paired":{"n":1515,"reference_mean":0.1939065398359456,"method_mean":0.14838693433628716,"delta_mean":0.04551960549965845,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.04551960549965845,"delta_median":0.042933426797389984,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1154,"losses":361,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.04230223423580827,0.0487236407548097],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"clip12_average":{"n":1536,"mean":0.263742578329685,"median":0.26519325251380604,"std":0.029381915502686123,"p25":0.24516932495559254,"p75":0.28342022808889544,"min":0.16167741765578586,"max":0.3683132007718086,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.2637127929630868,"delta_mean":0.03836360097955567,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.03836360097955567,"delta_median":0.03747395922740304,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1335,"losses":194,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.0366690884730199,0.040084565369644165],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"clip12_best":{"n":1536,"mean":0.29028442946825334,"median":0.2911085709929466,"std":0.029630785628305237,"p25":0.2720716595649719,"p75":0.31026798859238625,"min":0.18227215111255646,"max":0.38146576285362244,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.29026074484819053,"delta_mean":0.029874212718267235,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.029874212718267235,"delta_median":0.02777867019176483,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":1258,"losses":271,"ties":0,"ci95":[0.02820958672499466,0.03160848909546789],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}},"uni3d":{"n":1536,"mean":0.21173337681724055,"median":0.21281922608613968,"std":0.06585866989707988,"p25":0.16530033946037292,"p75":0.258354514837265,"min":0.014068232383579016,"max":0.41069184243679047,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.21188670462968914,"delta_mean":-0.017847530165092718,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.017847530165092718,"delta_median":-0.021001093089580536,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":590,"losses":939,"ties":0,"ci95":[-0.02133187323928892,-0.014326171548367843],"ci_source":"archived_paired_bootstrap"}}},"ours_b3":{"clip12_average":{"n":1535,"mean":0.30851541433511676,"median":0.30862067391475045,"std":0.022667980428581067,"p25":0.2933722740660111,"p75":0.3229410064717134,"min":0.23072936075429124,"max":0.3942741552988688,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.30207639394264246,"method_mean":0.3085178593342142,"delta_mean":-0.006441465391571781,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.006441465391571781,"delta_median":-0.003941083947817503,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":1039,"ties":490},"vs_base":{"n":1527,"delta_mean":0.010606301550364499,"delta_direction":"oracle_minus_base","wins":1138,"losses":389,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1535,"mean":0.32679408554727946,"median":0.3271361291408539,"std":0.02245124301394015,"p25":0.3114868998527527,"p75":0.34171155095100403,"min":0.24253183603286743,"max":0.41659019887447357,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.32013495756645777,"method_mean":0.3268160975646006,"delta_mean":-0.006681139998142824,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.006681139998142824,"delta_median":-0.0037168562412261963,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":1002,"ties":527},"vs_base":{"n":1527,"delta_mean":0.010398565376203046,"delta_direction":"oracle_minus_base","wins":1133,"losses":394,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1535,"mean":0.20711994262818695,"median":0.20666362345218658,"std":0.04952696640418364,"p25":0.17153195291757584,"p75":0.24232210591435432,"min":0.06136767193675041,"max":0.3526322990655899,"paired":{"n":1529,"reference_mean":0.19403917446459643,"method_mean":0.20714666690199865,"delta_mean":-0.013107492437402238,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.013107492437402238,"delta_median":-0.0067657530307769775,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":0,"losses":971,"ties":558},"vs_base":{"n":1527,"delta_mean":0.017169572083009912,"delta_direction":"oracle_minus_base","wins":1027,"losses":500,"ties":0}}},"ours_s2026":{"clip12_average":{"n":1532,"mean":0.30185919678976697,"median":0.3013086983313163,"std":0.023192724495043476,"p25":0.2869293102994561,"p75":0.3167956111331781,"min":0.22541578486561775,"max":0.3850158080458641,"paired":{"n":1527,"reference_mean":0.30212559389172877,"method_mean":0.3018100439194534,"delta_mean":0.00031554997227541126,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.00031554997227541126,"delta_median":8.437720437837193e-05,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":764,"losses":763,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1532,"mean":0.31986000421931166,"median":0.320101298391819,"std":0.023333936384170743,"p25":0.30463338643312454,"p75":0.3352648913860321,"min":0.23316876590251923,"max":0.4035656899213791,"paired":{"n":1527,"reference_mean":0.32018194851644227,"method_mean":0.3198302405463689,"delta_mean":0.0003517079700733527,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0003517079700733527,"delta_median":0.00045837461948394775,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":789,"losses":738,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1532,"mean":0.19201746074708942,"median":0.19292430952191353,"std":0.05180128173032186,"p25":0.1546049565076828,"p75":0.22956885397434235,"min":0.0435315053910017,"max":0.34785327315330505,"paired":{"n":1527,"reference_mean":0.19411249965497615,"method_mean":0.1920195241118998,"delta_mean":0.0020929755430763738,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0020929755430763738,"delta_median":0.0022012367844581604,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":819,"losses":708,"ties":0}}},"ours_s2028":{"clip12_average":{"n":1534,"mean":0.3022143151234675,"median":0.30249022133648396,"std":0.02352738523963019,"p25":0.28622938475261134,"p75":0.31705930829048157,"min":0.2065725860496362,"max":0.3942741552988688,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.3020844910623762,"method_mean":0.30220017433702867,"delta_mean":-0.000115683274652424,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":0.000115683274652424,"delta_median":-0.00045056454837322235,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":743,"losses":785,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1534,"mean":0.3200935600507601,"median":0.3201271519064903,"std":0.02355450264426434,"p25":0.3047805614769459,"p75":0.335868775844574,"min":0.22158712148666382,"max":0.4082103967666626,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.3201453505542266,"method_mean":0.3201019805344065,"delta_mean":4.337001982003607e-05,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-4.337001982003607e-05,"delta_median":0.00012674182653427124,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":770,"losses":758,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1534,"mean":0.1928162026693231,"median":0.19227030500769615,"std":0.05205253958950894,"p25":0.15617640689015388,"p75":0.2296454031020403,"min":-0.003638537134975195,"max":0.34074997901916504,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.19402192789251813,"method_mean":0.19283531987594674,"delta_mean":0.0011866080165713908,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0011866080165713908,"delta_median":0.001367412507534027,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":810,"losses":718,"ties":0}}},"scale2k":{"clip12_average":{"n":1532,"mean":0.29983128999944314,"median":0.300439993540446,"std":0.023428578311514642,"p25":0.28463432006537914,"p75":0.3156715339670578,"min":0.2185784950852394,"max":0.3747125516335169,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.3020614578554539,"method_mean":0.2998102987907786,"delta_mean":0.0022511590646752894,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0022511590646752894,"delta_median":0.0018463494877020148,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":854,"losses":671,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1532,"mean":0.3177511585929842,"median":0.31776586174964905,"std":0.02369520917948891,"p25":0.30242079496383667,"p75":0.334077924489975,"min":0.2317676991224289,"max":0.397859126329422,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.3201191282370051,"method_mean":0.3177502141526488,"delta_mean":0.0023689140843563394,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0023689140843563394,"delta_median":0.002050444483757019,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":870,"losses":655,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1532,"mean":0.19238821076783633,"median":0.19145516492426395,"std":0.04996158541681009,"p25":0.15781106986105442,"p75":0.22660598531365395,"min":0.045368846505880356,"max":0.337637722492218,"paired":{"n":1525,"reference_mean":0.19405101707479994,"method_mean":0.19244143332736413,"delta_mean":0.0016095837474357885,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0016095837474357885,"delta_median":0.0027741417288780212,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":824,"losses":701,"ties":0}}},"teacher_it":{"clip12_average":{"n":1535,"mean":0.3014953775195876,"median":0.3017934374511242,"std":0.02472120891018548,"p25":0.2860880366836985,"p75":0.3174675038705269,"min":0.18323054847617942,"max":0.3803638393680255,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.30210291306377696,"method_mean":0.3014577725828247,"delta_mean":0.0006451404809522704,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0006451404809522704,"delta_median":0.0003980696201324463,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":777,"losses":751,"ties":0}},"clip12_best":{"n":1535,"mean":0.3200355402130257,"median":0.3211834728717804,"std":0.025143526226808315,"p25":0.30288485437631607,"p75":0.3371630981564522,"min":0.18627292662858963,"max":0.3918279707431793,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.32015672931691425,"method_mean":0.3200165782689424,"delta_mean":0.00014015104797186027,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.00014015104797186027,"delta_median":3.0472874641418457e-05,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":765,"losses":763,"ties":0}},"uni3d":{"n":1535,"mean":0.1924474867397513,"median":0.1923035979270935,"std":0.0576848582147812,"p25":0.15207195654511452,"p75":0.2330082654953003,"min":-0.003180599771440029,"max":0.3434222489595413,"paired":{"n":1528,"reference_mean":0.19397145462178514,"method_mean":0.19246062316659945,"delta_mean":0.0015108314551856778,"delta_mean_method_minus_ours":-0.0015108314551856778,"delta_median":-0.00109858438372612,"delta_direction":"ours_minus_method","wins":748,"losses":780,"ties":0}}}},"by_category":{"C01":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":192,"mean":0.30824419508442386},"base":{"n":192,"mean":0.3011782146738066},"teacher":{"n":192,"mean":0.31300756882410496},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.28751325516754556},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.31211607511633904},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.2617084724705718},"ln3diff":{"n":192,"mean":0.2309952688681531},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.31540145031047156},"topia":{"n":191,"mean":0.26029124357339395},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.26954348367871717},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.3139291327453167}}},"C02":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":191,"mean":0.3026936024518433},"base":{"n":191,"mean":0.29965438692786617},"teacher":{"n":192,"mean":0.31176506265829734},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.2760155490800066},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.3033759063918195},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.27107316477405324},"ln3diff":{"n":190,"mean":0.21654466277870693},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.3034942090065063},"topia":{"n":192,"mean":0.2526077174342289},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.26893288779602803},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.3086385466255403}}},"C03":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":192,"mean":0.3065144090311757},"base":{"n":192,"mean":0.30235781484386987},"teacher":{"n":192,"mean":0.30778909713586067},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.25663680074568324},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.2983539495326113},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.2776327631387782},"ln3diff":{"n":189,"mean":0.23669258481781844},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.30374423736551154},"topia":{"n":190,"mean":0.25374389042947115},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.24184250528439102},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.3128781879236663}}},"C04":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":192,"mean":0.30463710679517436},"base":{"n":191,"mean":0.29987608267881793},"teacher":{"n":191,"mean":0.3017366733694576},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.25750044957062024},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.29006678691884086},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.2708133145707608},"ln3diff":{"n":192,"mean":0.23822248446716307},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.2977577683858625},"topia":{"n":192,"mean":0.251893260668213},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.2562044070962454},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.3094650136255142}}},"C05":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":190,"mean":0.3027255824456612},"base":{"n":191,"mean":0.30112271388280765},"teacher":{"n":190,"mean":0.30516339592766345},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.26865671605790137},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.29558870903242174},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.2675796443234301},"ln3diff":{"n":192,"mean":0.23990873709812555},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.2951328927819203},"topia":{"n":181,"mean":0.24024588369436797},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.2750053365533757},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.30919072890214416}}},"C06":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":192,"mean":0.30072887574917534},"base":{"n":192,"mean":0.29937050678482696},"teacher":{"n":192,"mean":0.3062527363427863},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.284475444398898},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.3056269128638734},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.28143434351012625},"ln3diff":{"n":191,"mean":0.25846898279447},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.30453314057861763},"topia":{"n":192,"mean":0.2629773087586121},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.27761288066135925},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.30866635361194816}}},"C07":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":188,"mean":0.2909322770457741},"base":{"n":187,"mean":0.27877217149046546},"teacher":{"n":192,"mean":0.2968339657559732},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.27316623303987503},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.2892403192042063},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.27648954028134337},"ln3diff":{"n":192,"mean":0.2428254573492773},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.2966673213522881},"topia":{"n":192,"mean":0.2612002251650362},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.25624524839481133},"ours_b3":{"n":191,"mean":0.2967730668807373}}},"C08":{"n_samples":192,"methods":{"ours":{"n":192,"mean":0.2999129108437854},"base":{"n":192,"mean":0.30010231156484224},"teacher":{"n":191,"mean":0.31082859319711126},"direct25":{"n":192,"mean":0.2839475551122127},"lgm":{"n":192,"mean":0.306752095370838},"shape":{"n":192,"mean":0.2839798411393228},"ln3diff":{"n":192,"mean":0.2569460209666027},"instantmesh":{"n":192,"mean":0.3065640886812212},"topia":{"n":192,"mean":0.27010055516277337},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":192,"mean":0.26455387717255185},"ours_b3":{"n":192,"mean":0.3085211263064088}}}},"by_split":{"complex_structure_test":{"n_samples":256,"methods":{"ours":{"n":256,"mean":0.3037907645048108},"base":{"n":254,"mean":0.2983673988521256},"teacher":{"n":254,"mean":0.3094811552617298},"direct25":{"n":256,"mean":0.27547658260785585},"lgm":{"n":256,"mean":0.3016789707859668},"shape":{"n":256,"mean":0.2752359300648095},"ln3diff":{"n":255,"mean":0.23810493637947672},"instantmesh":{"n":256,"mean":0.3041545825083934},"topia":{"n":255,"mean":0.2567954764597946},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":256,"mean":0.2680616241705138},"ours_b3":{"n":256,"mean":0.31128526881608803}}},"flux_id_test":{"n_samples":512,"methods":{"ours":{"n":510,"mean":0.30423146733295875},"base":{"n":509,"mean":0.29929770998041966},"teacher":{"n":510,"mean":0.3090338832899636},"direct25":{"n":512,"mean":0.2734110927873796},"lgm":{"n":512,"mean":0.30111790014173795},"shape":{"n":512,"mean":0.2744758821215025},"ln3diff":{"n":510,"mean":0.2385452990207115},"instantmesh":{"n":512,"mean":0.30518231730457046},"topia":{"n":507,"mean":0.2564086036139427},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":512,"mean":0.2684027264864805},"ours_b3":{"n":512,"mean":0.31054766486219404}}},"flux_ood_noun":{"n_samples":256,"methods":{"ours":{"n":254,"mean":0.2979268168742106},"base":{"n":256,"mean":0.29556903823201236},"teacher":{"n":256,"mean":0.3030153880051027},"direct25":{"n":256,"mean":0.27681091335155844},"lgm":{"n":256,"mean":0.2982005285593914},"shape":{"n":256,"mean":0.27151757687776507},"ln3diff":{"n":254,"mean":0.24255017008573757},"instantmesh":{"n":256,"mean":0.3009108175392612},"topia":{"n":254,"mean":0.25797543845327664},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":256,"mean":0.26674240691863815},"ours_b3":{"n":256,"mean":0.3043082327518884}}},"flux_ood_template":{"n_samples":256,"methods":{"ours":{"n":255,"mean":0.3007518315651253},"base":{"n":254,"mean":0.29568897958434237},"teacher":{"n":256,"mean":0.30361920550300664},"direct25":{"n":256,"mean":0.2734528743530973},"lgm":{"n":256,"mean":0.2994757881994398},"shape":{"n":256,"mean":0.2752660652428555},"ln3diff":{"n":256,"mean":0.23963783850316153},"instantmesh":{"n":256,"mean":0.30107299129546544},"topia":{"n":254,"mean":0.2598299497758036},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":256,"mean":0.252431219247228},"ours_b3":{"n":255,"mean":0.3067112520945813}}},"prior_hidden_regression":{"n_samples":128,"methods":{"ours":{"n":127,"mean":0.29947937141585695},"base":{"n":127,"mean":0.29812758093274483},"teacher":{"n":128,"mean":0.3084103531582514},"direct25":{"n":128,"mean":0.26915974445000757},"lgm":{"n":128,"mean":0.29845278890085564},"shape":{"n":128,"mean":0.26918845995290513},"ln3diff":{"n":128,"mean":0.23454827520617982},"instantmesh":{"n":128,"mean":0.2979633669553247},"topia":{"n":126,"mean":0.25071690871661145},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":128,"mean":0.2476983022109683},"ours_b3":{"n":128,"mean":0.30596635019173846}}},"short_simple_test":{"n_samples":128,"methods":{"ours":{"n":127,"mean":0.30352215417550776},"base":{"n":128,"mean":0.2997822018514853},"teacher":{"n":128,"mean":0.30339870923004736},"direct25":{"n":128,"mean":0.26758314853456494},"lgm":{"n":128,"mean":0.30004616708902176},"shape":{"n":128,"mean":0.2749354935028047},"ln3diff":{"n":127,"mean":0.2519866126758142},"instantmesh":{"n":128,"mean":0.30397324383375235},"topia":{"n":126,"mean":0.2554138485322554},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":128,"mean":0.2691312311265695},"ours_b3":{"n":128,"mean":0.30940436003826716}}}},"ours_seed_detail":{"OURS-seed2026-step12000":{"clip12_average":{"n":1532,"mean":0.30185919678976697,"median":0.3013086983313163,"std":0.023192724495043476,"p25":0.2869293102994561,"p75":0.3167956111331781,"min":0.22541578486561775,"max":0.3850158080458641},"clip12_best":{"n":1532,"mean":0.31986000421931166,"median":0.320101298391819,"std":0.023333936384170743,"p25":0.30463338643312454,"p75":0.3352648913860321,"min":0.23316876590251923,"max":0.4035656899213791},"uni3d":{"n":1532,"mean":0.19201746074708942,"median":0.19292430952191353,"std":0.05180128173032186,"p25":0.1546049565076828,"p75":0.22956885397434235,"min":0.0435315053910017,"max":0.34785327315330505}},"OURS-seed2027-step12000":{"clip12_average":{"n":1529,"mean":0.30207639394264246,"median":0.3017452172935009,"std":0.0230978815151579,"p25":0.28737775733073556,"p75":0.317499486108621,"min":0.21267693241437277,"max":0.37935277447104454},"clip12_best":{"n":1529,"mean":0.32013495756645777,"median":0.32081620395183563,"std":0.02311403770114487,"p25":0.3048715889453888,"p75":0.3351796567440033,"min":0.24017129093408585,"max":0.41659019887447357},"uni3d":{"n":1529,"mean":0.19403917446459643,"median":0.1934235841035843,"std":0.05232589827868412,"p25":0.15858720988035202,"p75":0.23021069169044495,"min":0.046505773440003395,"max":0.3526322990655899}},"OURS-seed2028-step12000":{"clip12_average":{"n":1534,"mean":0.3022143151234675,"median":0.30249022133648396,"std":0.02352738523963019,"p25":0.28622938475261134,"p75":0.31705930829048157,"min":0.2065725860496362,"max":0.3942741552988688},"clip12_best":{"n":1534,"mean":0.3200935600507601,"median":0.3201271519064903,"std":0.02355450264426434,"p25":0.3047805614769459,"p75":0.335868775844574,"min":0.22158712148666382,"max":0.4082103967666626},"uni3d":{"n":1534,"mean":0.1928162026693231,"median":0.19227030500769615,"std":0.05205253958950894,"p25":0.15617640689015388,"p75":0.2296454031020403,"min":-0.003638537134975195,"max":0.34074997901916504}}},"ours_best_of_3_detail":{"clip12_average":{"selected_seed_counts":{"OURS-seed2026-step12000":491,"OURS-seed2027-step12000":490,"OURS-seed2028-step12000":554},"complete_best_of_3":1526},"clip12_best":{"selected_seed_counts":{"OURS-seed2026-step12000":481,"OURS-seed2027-step12000":527,"OURS-seed2028-step12000":527},"complete_best_of_3":1526},"uni3d":{"selected_seed_counts":{"OURS-seed2026-step12000":468,"OURS-seed2028-step12000":509,"OURS-seed2027-step12000":558},"complete_best_of_3":1526}},"quarantined":{"reference_bid":"OURS-seed2027-step12000","metrics":["ulip"],"methods":{"ours":{"n":1529,"mean":-0.0327229707451882,"median":-0.03380809258669615,"std":0.05111286973096631,"p25":-0.06630625762045383,"p75":0.0035604191944003105,"min":-0.21300861239433289,"max":0.15802733600139618},"base":{"n":1528,"mean":-0.03425875682277417,"median":-0.03250532643869519,"std":0.04971321809598941,"p25":-0.0659016827121377,"p75":-0.0015698958886787295,"min":-0.1951919123530388,"max":0.1231127567589283},"teacher":{"n":1532,"mean":-0.031273142215428026,"median":-0.028883926570415497,"std":0.05144927118322036,"p25":-0.0656736996024847,"p75":0.0040432910900563,"min":-0.20123401284217834,"max":0.1386151984333992},"direct25":{"n":1536,"mean":0.025625837554192305,"median":0.024573938571847975,"std":0.050215227766431024,"p25":-0.00951908016577363,"p75":0.05956003209576011,"min":-0.15376141667366028,"max":0.21560486406087875},"shape":{"n":1536,"mean":0.03260872597578176,"median":0.03018232760950923,"std":0.0530845171588351,"p25":-0.002536800689995289,"p75":0.0660990378819406,"min":-0.13024970144033432,"max":0.22498173266649246},"ln3diff":{"n":1530,"mean":0.024894897219096462,"median":0.022935941815376282,"std":0.05055301014792466,"p25":-0.0102428391110152,"p75":0.05852490197867155,"min":-0.13048815727233887,"max":0.22069348394870758},"instantmesh":{"n":1536,"mean":0.022171754614343325,"median":0.01863417960703373,"std":0.05136971170404212,"p25":-0.013375371927395463,"p75":0.05523483850993216,"min":-0.1319255754351616,"max":0.22931556403636932},"topia":{"n":1522,"mean":0.033892697899886276,"median":0.03209332935512066,"std":0.052918862798825864,"p25":-0.0026665569748729467,"p75":0.06849956139922142,"min":-0.17918578535318375,"max":0.25280915200710297},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"n":1536,"mean":0.054679209481188686,"median":0.054953510873019695,"std":0.06019524031253938,"p25":0.01180983887752518,"p75":0.09442460257560015,"min":-0.1303514838218689,"max":0.24540925770998}}},"coverage":{"ours":{"clip12_average":1529,"clip12_best":1529,"uni3d":1529},"base":{"clip12_average":1528,"clip12_best":1528,"uni3d":1528},"teacher":{"clip12_average":1532,"clip12_best":1532,"uni3d":1532},"direct25":{"clip12_average":1536,"clip12_best":1536,"uni3d":1536},"lgm":{"clip12_average":1536,"clip12_best":1536,"uni3d":0},"shape":{"clip12_average":1536,"clip12_best":1536,"uni3d":1536},"ln3diff":{"clip12_average":1530,"clip12_best":1530,"uni3d":1530},"instantmesh":{"clip12_average":1536,"clip12_best":1536,"uni3d":1536},"topia":{"clip12_average":1522,"clip12_best":1522,"uni3d":1522},"hunyuan_fr40k":{"clip12_average":1536,"clip12_best":1536,"uni3d":1536},"ours_b3":{"clip12_average":1535,"clip12_best":1535,"uni3d":1535},"ours_s2026":{"clip12_average":1532,"clip12_best":1532,"uni3d":1532},"ours_s2028":{"clip12_average":1534,"clip12_best":1534,"uni3d":1534},"scale2k":{"clip12_average":1532,"clip12_best":1532,"uni3d":1532},"teacher_it":{"clip12_average":1535,"clip12_best":1535,"uni3d":1535}},"provenance":{"native_per_prompt":"H100:.../reanalysis/corrected_semantic_completion_v1/per_prompt_metrics.jsonl","ours_best_of_3":"H100:.../reanalysis/corrected_semantic_completion_v1/ours_best_of_3_semantic.jsonl","external_per_prompt":"cloud48:/root/fsas/external_baseline_expansion_20260913/statistics/<BASELINE_ID>/per_prompt.jsonl","archived_paired_stats":"comparison_figure_handoff_20260915/final_statistics/FINAL_COMPARISON_TABLE.json"}}